• Film
  • Gaming
  • Geek:Life
  • Music
  • Television
  • Shopping
  • Forums
  • The Digital Fix

  • Home
  • Film Reviews
  • DVD Reviews
  • Blu-ray Reviews
  • Features
  • Trailers
  • News
  • Podcasts
  • Reviews

    Allfilm reviewBlu-RayDVD

    Transformers: The Last Knight

    Chris Rogers

    Edith Walks

    Steven Sheehan

    Souvenir

    Steven Sheehan

    Harmonium

    Ben Pinsent

    Diabolique

    Jon Meakin

    Unforgiven - 25th Anniversary 4K Restoration

    Geoff Dearth

    Spear

    Gary Couzens

    By the Time It Gets Dark

    Steven Sheehan

    Whitney: Can I Be Me

    Hel Harding-Jones

    Housekeeping

    David Poplar

    Churchill

    Daniel Theophanous

    Slack Bay

    Steven Sheehan

    Destination Unknown

    Steven Sheehan

    John Wick: Chapter 2

    Geoff Dearth

    Ip Man: The Final Fight

    Ben Pinsent

    Minute Bodies: The Intimate World of F. Percy Smith

    Gary Couzens

    Features

    The TDF Interview: Claire FergusonSteven Sheehan
    Sofia Coppola and Her FilmsLewis Knight The TDF Interview: Michaël Dudok de WitPaul Farrell How Far Is Too Far With Cinema Etiquette?Sarah Miles The TDF Interview: Juno Temple Steven Sheehan The TDF Interview: Ellie Kendrick Steven Sheehan

    News

    Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom Revealed As The Next Instalment

    Steven Sheehan

    First trailer and release date for Battle of the Sexes announced

    Steven Sheehan

    [Exclusive Clip] "Baby Driver" - 'I'm a Driver'

    James Perkins

    WTF Movie News Of The Day - Phil Lord and Chris Miller Leave Han Solo Movie Over "Creative Differences"

    Colin Polonowski

    'Thank You For Your Service' Trailer Released

    Steven Sheehan

    Eight films to watch out for on Freeview TV this week

    Ronan O'Meara

    Mexican drama The Untamed coming to the UK soon

    Steven Sheehan

    Arrow release trailer for political thriller, Scribe

    Colin Polonowski

    Netflix's Nobody Speak: Trials of the Free Press

    Steven Sheehan

    Watch the trailer for Daddy's Home 2

    Colin Polonowski

    First trailer for Goodbye Christopher Robin released

    Colin Polonowski

    Advertisement

    Latest Deal

    Stay Connected

    Like+1FollowWatchSee

    Advertisement

    The Digital Fix

    © Copyright Poisonous Monkey Ltd, Registered in England & Wales. Company No 0652630

    Stay Connected

    Like+1FollowWatchSee

    The Digital Fix

    The Digital Fix
    Film @ The Digital FixGaming @ The Digital FixGeek:Life @ The Digital FixMusic @ The Digital FixTelevision @ The Digital Fix
    The Digital Fix

    Error 404

    Page Not Found

    Oops. You took a wrong turn...

    back to homepage

    The Digital Fix

    The Digital Fix
    Film @ The Digital FixGaming @ The Digital FixGeek:Life @ The Digital FixMusic @ The Digital FixTelevision @ The Digital Fix
    The Digital Fix

    Error 404

    Page Not Found

    Oops. You took a wrong turn...

    back to homepage

    Op-Ed: Embrace The New, Academy!

    • 04:06 on 14th Dec 2016
    • By Charlie Brigden

    Watch out – it’s an Oscar hot take!

    By Charlie Brigden

    Okay, so controversy has yet again reared its ugly head now that the list of film scores eligible for a 2017 Academy Award have been revealed. Of a reel of 145 scores there are some eye-opening omissions, including Kim Allen Kluge and Kathryn Kluge’s score to Martin Scorsese’s Silence, Lesley Barber’s Manchester By The Sea, and probably the biggest shock, Jóhann Jóhannsson’s Arrival. The latter was hotly tipped for a possible win and had just been nominated for a Golden Globe.

    The standard line that the Academy offers is that it’s about pre-existing music diluting the original score; in Manchester‘s case it’s music by Handel, Massenet, Ella Fitzerald, and more; for Arrival it’s a piece by Max Richter used twice. This is not a new thing, both Birdman by Antonio Sanchez and The Revenant by Ryuichi Sakamoto were disqualified in recent years, as well as Cliff Martinez’s Drive. Initially, Howard Shore was told that his score for the second Lord of the Rings film – The Two Towers – would be ineligible due to its use of themes from its predecessor, but this was pulled back as being a “late change” that would be implemented the following year. While Towers was not nominated, the following year its successor The Return of the King was, and won the Oscar.

    So what is suggested here is a combination of inconsistency and inflexibility. Another example of this is another recent score, 2011’s The Artist, which primarily featured a score by Ludovic Bource. I say “primarily” because its final scene used music from another movie, specifically the ‘Scene D’Amour’ piece from Bernard Herrmann’s score to Vertigo. The score took home the Oscar in 2012 to some controversy, not least from Vertigo star Kim Novak who clumsily accused director Michael Hazanavicius of “rape” for using it (a very poor choice of words). Even Ennio Morricone’s The Hateful Eight, which won the 2015 award was partially created out of music unused for another film, the 1982 John Carpenter shocker The Thing, although admittedly that is a much greyer area.

    So why is the Academy so haphazardly inconsistent? Why do these controversies keep rearing their heads again and again? I can’t answer that specifically, I have no access to the Academy and their dealings, although I know there is a strict no appeals rule for this. Some have even said it’s a mathematical issue, that some look at music sheets submitted and rule by a percentage. Would it not be easier if someone – a panel perhaps – actually looked at these films and examined in context the way the music affects the film, and whether it truly dilutes it or enriches?

    Another possible solution is to create a category for music supervision. We know that the credit of “music supervisor” is an important achievement, especially recently where there’s been a breakout of people like George Drakoulias who has worked on everything from Zoolander to Zodiac, or Brian Reitzell on Sofia Coppola’s pictures. With the kind of soundtracks that are getting produced a lot more today, maybe it’s time for the Academy to open the field a bit more and show some appreciation for the different ways film music is created, which in turn might allow more of a celebration of the diversity of the ways music is used in film, instead of alienating artists, particularly someone like Jóhann Jóhannsson, now one of the top composers working in the medium today.

    The music hasn’t changed but the technology and techniques have. Let’s embrace that, not reject it.

      Advertisement

      Facebook

      Advertisement

      Price Drops!


      From the TDF Network

      The Digital Fix

      The Digital Fix
      Film @ The Digital FixGaming @ The Digital FixGeek:Life @ The Digital FixMusic @ The Digital FixTelevision @ The Digital Fix
      The Digital Fix

      Error 404

      Page Not Found

      Oops. You took a wrong turn...

      back to homepage